Publication Ethics & Malpractice Statement
Our principles and procedures for protecting research integrity, editorial independence, responsible peer review and the accuracy of the scholarly record.
1. Purpose and Ethical Commitment
International Journal of Sub-Saharan African Research (IJSSAR) is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics, research integrity, editorial independence and accountability. The journal recognises that the credibility of scholarly publishing depends on the honesty of authors, the impartiality of reviewers and editors, the reliability of research evidence and the responsible preservation of the scholarly record.
This Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement establishes the ethical principles and procedures governing the conduct of authors, reviewers, editors and other individuals involved in the publication process. It addresses the prevention, assessment and handling of suspected research and publication misconduct, including plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, authorship disputes, undisclosed conflicts of interest, peer-review manipulation and other practices that may undermine scholarly integrity.
IJSSAR draws on the principles and Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), https://publication-ethics.org/ (COPE), alongside recognised standards of responsible research conduct. The journal applies these principles in a manner appropriate to its multidisciplinary scope and the circumstances of individual cases.
This statement should be read alongside the journal's Journal Policies and Instructions for Authors.
2. Fundamental Principles of Publication Ethics
All parties involved in the publication process are expected to uphold the following principles:
- Honesty: Research findings, methods, sources, authorship details and declarations must be accurate and must not be fabricated or misrepresented.
- Originality: Submitted work must be original, with appropriate acknowledgement of sources, contributions and prior dissemination on which it builds.
- Transparency: Relevant funding, conflicts of interest, ethical approvals, data availability and material use of AI-assisted tools must be disclosed as required.
- Fairness and impartiality: Editorial and peer-review decisions must be based on scholarly merit and established editorial standards, without discrimination or improper influence.
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts, review reports, personal information and confidential editorial communications must be handled responsibly.
- Accountability: Authors, reviewers and editors are responsible for fulfilling their respective ethical obligations.
- Respect for the scholarly record: Errors and substantiated ethical concerns must be addressed through appropriate editorial action rather than concealed or silently disregarded.
3. Responsibilities of Authors
Authors submitting manuscripts to IJSSAR are responsible for the integrity, accuracy and originality of their work. By submitting a manuscript, authors confirm that they have read and agree to comply with the journal's applicable policies.
Authors must:
- Present research methods, evidence, analysis and findings accurately and transparently.
- Ensure that sources, quotations, ideas, data and materials derived from other works are appropriately acknowledged.
- Avoid plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, data falsification, inappropriate image manipulation and other forms of research or publication misconduct.
- Ensure that all listed authors meet the journal's authorship requirements and have approved the submitted and final versions.
- Disclose relevant funding, conflicts of interest, prior dissemination, research ethics approval and data availability, where applicable.
- Obtain necessary permissions for copyrighted or otherwise restricted materials included in a manuscript.
- Respond honestly and promptly to reasonable editorial requests for clarification, supporting documentation or corrections.
- Cooperate with legitimate investigations into concerns about their work.
- Correct material errors or inaccuracies identified before or after publication.
- Comply with the journal's requirements for the disclosure and responsible use of generative AI and other AI-assisted tools.
Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal. They must not misrepresent the status of a manuscript submitted elsewhere, manipulate citations, fabricate peer-review information or engage intermediaries to secure acceptance through improper means.
4. Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for ensuring that editorial decisions are fair, independent, confidential and consistent with the journal's scope and standards.
Editors must:
- Assess manuscripts according to scholarly merit, originality, relevance, methodological rigour, ethical compliance and quality of presentation.
- Apply editorial standards consistently and without discrimination based on authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, institutional affiliation, personal beliefs or other irrelevant characteristics.
- Ensure that financial considerations, article processing charge (APC) payments, commercial interests or external pressure do not determine acceptance or rejection.
- Select appropriate reviewers and consider their expertise, independence, availability and potential conflicts of interest.
- Protect the confidentiality of manuscripts, reviewers' identities where applicable, review reports and editorial communications.
- Disclose and appropriately manage their own conflicts of interest.
- Avoid handling manuscripts where personal, professional, financial or institutional relationships could compromise impartiality.
- Respond appropriately to suspected misconduct, complaints, appeals and concerns about published articles.
- Maintain appropriate records of editorial decisions and significant actions taken in response to ethical concerns.
- Issue corrections, expressions of concern or retractions where warranted to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.
Editors must not use unpublished information from submitted manuscripts for personal advantage or permit another party to exploit confidential manuscript content. Editorial authority must not be used to demand irrelevant citations, secure personal benefits or obtain favourable treatment for particular authors.
The Editor-in-Chief retains overall responsibility for final editorial decisions, subject to the journal's established procedures and the need to manage conflicts of interest appropriately.
5. Responsibilities of Reviewers
Peer reviewers contribute to the quality, reliability and relevance of scholarly publications. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, evidence-based and constructive assessments.
Reviewers must:
- Accept assignments only where they have appropriate expertise and can complete the review within the agreed period.
- Disclose any conflict of interest that could affect, or reasonably appear to affect, their assessment.
- Evaluate manuscripts impartially, using scholarly arguments and evidence rather than personal criticism.
- Identify relevant published work that has not been acknowledged, where reasonably possible.
- Alert the editor to suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data irregularities, inappropriate citation practices or other concerns affecting research integrity.
- Treat manuscripts and review reports as confidential and not share them without editorial permission.
- Avoid using unpublished data, arguments, methods or findings from a manuscript for personal research or professional advantage.
- Refrain from coercive citation requests, discriminatory remarks, personal attacks or other inappropriate conduct.
- Disclose any permitted use of AI-assisted tools in reviewing where required by the journal and ensure that confidentiality is preserved.
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or review materials to unauthorised AI systems. A reviewer who discovers a conflict of interest after accepting an assignment must inform the editor promptly and withdraw from the review where necessary.
6. Authorship and Contributorship
Authorship must reflect meaningful scholarly contribution and accountability for the work. The inclusion or exclusion of an individual as an author must not be used to confer undeserved credit, conceal responsibility or settle personal or institutional disputes.
All listed authors must have made a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, the acquisition or analysis of data, the interpretation of findings, or another significant aspect of the research; participated in drafting or critically revising the manuscript; approved the final version; and accepted accountability for their contributions and the integrity of the work.
Individuals whose contributions do not meet the authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately, with their permission where necessary. Administrative support, routine data collection, funding acquisition or general supervision alone does not automatically establish authorship.
The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that:
- All listed authors have approved the submission and final manuscript.
- Author names, affiliations and contribution statements are accurate.
- Required declarations are complete.
- All authors are informed of material editorial communications.
- Any proposed change to authorship is supported by a clear justification and written agreement from all affected authors.
Requests to add, remove or reorder authors after submission must be made to the editorial office with the reasons for the change and the written agreement of all affected authors. The journal may suspend processing while an authorship dispute is investigated.
Where authors cannot resolve a substantive dispute, the journal may seek clarification from the relevant institution or institutions. The journal will not determine institutional employment or ownership disputes beyond its editorial remit.
7. Plagiarism, Self-Plagiarism and Duplicate Publication
IJSSAR does not accept plagiarism or other forms of inappropriate appropriation of intellectual work.
Plagiarism includes presenting another person's words, ideas, data, methods, images or other intellectual contributions as one's own without adequate acknowledgement. It may occur in direct quotations, paraphrased material, translations, figures, tables, datasets or other forms of scholarly content.
The journal also recognises that inappropriate reuse of an author's own previously published material, commonly described as self-plagiarism or text recycling, may mislead readers about the originality of a submission. The assessment of such cases will consider the extent and nature of the overlap, the context, the disclosure provided and the relevant publication requirements.
Duplicate publication includes publishing substantially the same work more than once without appropriate disclosure or justification. Authors must disclose relevant prior publication, related manuscripts, preprints and conference versions where required so that the editor can assess the relationship between the materials.
IJSSAR screens manuscripts using Turnitin or an appropriate similarity-detection service. A similarity score of 20% or below is the journal's general screening benchmark, but the score is not a definitive measure of plagiarism. The editor will consider the nature, location, attribution and significance of any identified overlap.
Depending on the circumstances, concerns may lead to clarification requests, additional assessment, revision, rejection, correction, retraction or other appropriate action.
8. Research Misconduct and Data Integrity
Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
- Fabrication: Making up data, observations, participants, results or research records.
- Falsification: Manipulating research materials, methods, data, images or results in a way that misrepresents the research.
- Plagiarism: Appropriating another person's work or ideas without appropriate acknowledgement.
- Inappropriate image manipulation: Altering, selectively presenting or misrepresenting images in a manner that distorts the underlying evidence.
- Citation manipulation: Adding irrelevant or coercive citations, manipulating references to inflate citation counts or engaging in citation arrangements intended to distort scholarly evaluation.
- Authorship misconduct: Misrepresenting contributions, adding honorary authors, omitting deserving contributors or engaging in unauthorised authorship changes.
- Peer-review manipulation: Fabricating reviewer identities, supplying false reviewer contact details, interfering with reviewer selection or otherwise compromising the independence of peer review.
- Misrepresentation of research: Reporting methods, results, approvals, funding or other research details inaccurately.
- Undisclosed duplicate or redundant publication: Concealing substantial overlap with previously published or concurrently submitted work.
Authors are expected to maintain appropriate research records and ensure that reported findings can be supported by reliable evidence. Where concerns arise, the journal may request data, analysis files, ethical approval documentation, permissions or other relevant materials, subject to applicable privacy, confidentiality and legal requirements.
The journal does not presume misconduct solely because an allegation has been made. Concerns will be assessed on the available evidence, with a fair opportunity for relevant parties to respond.
9. Research Ethics and Protection of Participants
Research involving human participants, personal data, identifiable records, vulnerable populations or other ethically sensitive materials must comply with applicable laws, institutional requirements and recognised ethical principles.
Where required, authors must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee or institutional review board before conducting the research. The manuscript should identify the approving body and provide the relevant approval information. Where formal approval was not required, authors may be asked to explain the basis for that determination.
Authors must obtain informed consent where required and take appropriate steps to protect participants' privacy, dignity, safety and confidentiality. Research involving children or other vulnerable populations requires particular attention to consent, assent, safeguarding and applicable ethical requirements.
Identifiable information, photographs, recordings or case details must not be published without an appropriate legal and ethical basis and the necessary permissions or consent. Authors must ensure that the publication of research findings does not expose participants to avoidable harm.
For research involving animals, authors must comply with applicable animal welfare laws and institutional ethical requirements and provide relevant approval information where required.
Where a manuscript raises significant concerns about participant protection, consent, research approval or the lawful use of personal data, the journal may request further information, seek independent advice, suspend consideration or decline publication.
10. Journal Policy on Ethical Oversight
IJSSAR is committed to upholding the highest standards of ethical conduct in research, scholarly communication and academic publishing. Ethical oversight is an essential consideration in the journal's manuscript evaluation and publication processes and applies to all research submitted for publication.
10.1 Research Involving Human Participants
Research involving human participants, human subjects, identifiable personal information or human biological materials must be conducted in accordance with recognised ethical principles governing the protection, dignity, rights, privacy and welfare of participants. Authors must obtain prior approval from an appropriate institutional research ethics committee, institutional review board or recognised equivalent body, where applicable.
Manuscripts reporting such research must include an ethics statement identifying the approving institution or committee and the approval reference number, where available. Where a study has been exempted from ethical review, authors must provide the name of the body granting the exemption and an explanation of the basis for the exemption.
10.2 Informed Consent and Protection of Participants
Authors must obtain appropriate informed consent from research participants before collecting or using their information, in accordance with applicable ethical requirements. Participants must be adequately informed about the purpose of the research, their involvement, the intended use of the information provided and their rights concerning participation.
Where research involves children or individuals unable to provide legally valid consent independently, appropriate consent must be obtained from parents, guardians or legally authorised representatives, alongside assent from participants where appropriate.
Separate consent for publication must be obtained where manuscripts contain identifiable personal information, photographs, clinical details, case descriptions or other materials that could reasonably reveal a participant's identity. Authors must ensure that participants' confidentiality, anonymity and privacy are adequately protected.
10.3 Research Involving Vulnerable Populations
Research involving vulnerable individuals or groups, including children, persons with disabilities, displaced persons, individuals in situations of conflict, economically disadvantaged populations and other groups requiring additional protection, must incorporate appropriate ethical safeguards.
Authors must demonstrate that the research minimised potential harm, respected participants' rights and dignity, addressed possible power imbalances and obtained appropriate consent and ethical approval. The journal may subject such manuscripts to additional ethical scrutiny where the nature of the research warrants it.
10.4 Research Involving Animals
Research involving animals must comply with applicable institutional, national and international standards for animal welfare and the humane treatment of animals. Authors must obtain approval from an appropriate animal research ethics committee or equivalent regulatory authority, where required, and provide relevant approval details in the manuscript.
Authors must demonstrate that appropriate measures were taken to minimise pain, distress and unnecessary harm to animals. Research that involves unjustifiable cruelty, unnecessary suffering or serious breaches of recognised animal welfare standards will not be considered for publication.
10.5 Privacy, Confidentiality and Responsible Use of Data
Authors must respect the confidentiality and privacy of individuals, institutions, organisations and communities involved in their research. Personally identifiable, confidential or sensitive information must not be disclosed without appropriate authorisation and, where necessary, informed consent.
Research involving private records, restricted institutional documents, confidential communications, protected databases or other non-public information must be conducted with appropriate permissions and ethical safeguards. Authors must ensure that the collection, storage, processing and use of research data comply with relevant data protection requirements and applicable ethical standards.
10.6 Secondary Data, Publicly Available Information and Digital Research
Research based on secondary data, publicly accessible records, social media content, online platforms, archival materials and other digital sources must be conducted responsibly and in accordance with relevant ethical and legal requirements.
Authors must consider the privacy expectations, potential vulnerability and reasonable expectations of individuals whose information or online activities are examined, particularly where the material contains sensitive or personally identifiable information. Public accessibility alone does not automatically remove the need for ethical consideration, informed consent or additional safeguards.
Where ethical approval is not required for a particular study, authors should explain the basis for that determination and provide evidence of an institutional or other appropriate exemption where applicable.
10.7 Research Permits, Environmental Protection and Community Rights
Research involving protected environments, endangered species, natural resources, indigenous communities, traditional knowledge, culturally sensitive materials or restricted research sites must comply with applicable laws, regulations, permit requirements and recognised ethical standards.
Authors are responsible for obtaining the necessary permissions and ensuring that their research does not involve unauthorised exploitation, environmental harm or violations of community rights.
10.8 Editorial Assessment and Ethical Compliance
IJSSAR reserves the right to examine the ethical dimensions of any manuscript at submission, during peer review or after publication. Editors may request additional information, ethical approval documents, evidence of informed consent, research permits or other relevant documentation where necessary to establish compliance with applicable ethical standards.
Where concerns arise regarding ethical misconduct, inadequate participant protection, questionable consent procedures, unauthorised use of confidential information or other ethical violations, the journal will investigate the matter and may consult relevant institutional authorities or independent experts.
Manuscripts that fail to meet the journal's ethical requirements may be returned for clarification, rejected or withdrawn from consideration. Where ethical violations are identified after publication, the journal may issue an appropriate correction, expression of concern or retraction, depending on the nature and seriousness of the violation.
10.9 Editorial Independence and Ethical Publishing Practices
IJSSAR maintains that editorial decisions must be based on the scholarly merit, originality, relevance and ethical acceptability of submitted manuscripts. Financial considerations, advertising, sponsorship, institutional affiliations, commercial interests or other external pressures must not compromise editorial independence or influence peer-review outcomes and publication decisions.
The journal is committed to transparent publishing practices, fair treatment of authors and reviewers, responsible management of publication-related fees and the prevention of unethical business and editorial practices.
Through this policy, IJSSAR seeks to ensure that all research published in the journal respects human dignity, protects research participants, promotes responsible scholarly inquiry and upholds the integrity of the scholarly record.
11. Conflicts of Interest / Competing Interests
IJSSAR is committed to ensuring transparency, editorial independence and impartiality throughout its publication process. Authors, reviewers and editors are required to disclose any financial, professional, institutional, personal or other relationships or circumstances that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, their work, judgement or decisions relating to a manuscript.
Conflicts of interest may include, but are not limited to, employment, consultancy, paid advisory roles, financial holdings, research funding, personal or family relationships, professional rivalries, institutional affiliations, academic collaborations or other interests that may compromise, or appear to compromise, objectivity.
Authors must declare all actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest at the time of manuscript submission. Where no such conflicts exist, authors must explicitly state that they have no conflicts of interest to declare. All sources of research funding must also be disclosed, including the role of funders, where applicable, in the design, conduct, analysis, interpretation or publication of the research.
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest to the handling editor before accepting or undertaking a review. Where a conflict exists that could affect their impartiality, they must decline the review assignment.
Editors must disclose any conflicts of interest and must not participate in the evaluation, peer review or publication decisions concerning manuscripts in which they have a competing interest. Such manuscripts will be reassigned to an independent editor who will oversee the editorial process and make publication recommendations without undue influence.
Where a conflict of interest is suspected or identified, the journal will assess the circumstances and take appropriate measures to safeguard the integrity and impartiality of the editorial and peer-review processes. These may include requesting additional disclosures, replacing a reviewer or editor, obtaining independent assessments or publishing a conflict-of-interest declaration, where necessary.
If an undisclosed conflict of interest is discovered after publication, IJSSAR will investigate the matter and determine the appropriate corrective action. Depending on its nature and significance, this may include publishing a disclosure statement, correction, editorial notice or, in serious cases involving compromised research integrity or material breaches of publication ethics, retracting the affected article.
12. Data Sharing and Reproducibility
IJSSAR is committed to promoting research transparency, accountability, verifiability and the responsible sharing of research data. The journal recognises that access to relevant research data, materials and methodological information enhances the credibility of scholarly findings, facilitates independent verification and encourages further research and knowledge development.
12.1 Data Availability and Sharing
Authors are encouraged to make the data, materials and other resources supporting the findings of their research available to readers, wherever ethically, legally and practically possible. Such materials may include datasets, interview instruments, questionnaires, codebooks, research protocols, analytical procedures, software code, statistical outputs and other relevant supplementary materials.
Where research data are publicly available, authors should deposit them in an appropriate, reputable and accessible institutional, disciplinary or general-purpose data repository and provide the corresponding link or persistent identifier, such as a Digital Object Identifier (DOI), in the manuscript. Authors should appropriately acknowledge and cite any datasets or materials used in their research, whether generated independently or obtained from external sources.
12.2 Data Availability Statements
Authors of all submissions involving research data are required to include a Data Availability Statement indicating whether the data supporting the findings are publicly available, available upon reasonable request, restricted by ethical or legal considerations, or not applicable to the study.
Where data cannot be made publicly available, authors must provide a clear explanation, including any relevant ethical, confidentiality, privacy, contractual or legal restrictions. A statement that data are available upon request should identify the appropriate contact point and any applicable access conditions.
For articles that do not generate or analyse research data, such as theoretical, conceptual or certain review papers, authors should indicate that data sharing is not applicable.
12.3 Confidentiality, Privacy and Ethical Restrictions
IJSSAR recognises that not all research data can or should be made publicly accessible. Authors must protect the privacy, confidentiality, safety and rights of research participants and comply with applicable ethical standards, institutional requirements, data protection regulations and relevant legal obligations.
Personally identifiable information, confidential interviews, sensitive personal records and other protected research materials must not be disclosed without appropriate authorisation and informed consent. Where necessary, authors should anonymise or de-identify datasets before sharing them. Where anonymisation cannot adequately protect participants, restricted or controlled access may be appropriate.
The journal does not require authors to disclose data where doing so would violate ethical obligations, participant consent, confidentiality agreements or applicable laws.
12.4 Research Reproducibility and Methodological Transparency
Authors are expected to provide sufficiently clear, accurate and detailed descriptions of their research designs, methods, procedures, instruments, sampling techniques, data collection processes and analytical approaches to enable qualified researchers to understand, assess and, where feasible, reproduce or independently verify their findings.
Where applicable, authors should provide information about the software, statistical tools, analytical models, computational procedures and relevant technical resources used in conducting their research. Supporting materials, including research instruments, code, protocols and analytical documentation, should be made available as supplementary materials or through appropriate repositories, where ethically and legally permissible.
For qualitative, quantitative and mixed-methods studies, the level of methodological detail should be appropriate to the research design and discipline. Reproducibility does not necessarily require public disclosure of confidential raw data, particularly where doing so would compromise research participants or violate ethical obligations.
12.5 Editorial Oversight and Compliance
IJSSAR reserves the right to request reasonable access to relevant research data, supporting materials, research instruments or methodological documentation during manuscript evaluation where necessary to clarify, verify or assess the reliability of reported findings. Such requests will be subject to appropriate confidentiality, ethical and legal safeguards.
Where concerns arise regarding the authenticity, accuracy, accessibility or consistency of reported data and research findings, the journal will investigate the matter in accordance with its publication ethics and research misconduct procedures. Where necessary, the journal may request clarification, supporting evidence or additional documentation from the authors and take appropriate editorial action.
Failure to provide a required Data Availability Statement, provide reasonable clarification concerning research data or address substantiated concerns about data integrity may result in editorial action, including manuscript rejection, publication correction or retraction, depending on the nature and seriousness of the matter.
Through this policy, IJSSAR seeks to uphold responsible data management, methodological transparency and the integrity and reproducibility of scholarly research.
13. Generative Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Tools
IJSSAR recognises that generative AI and other AI-assisted tools may be used in aspects of research and manuscript preparation. Their use must not undermine authorship accountability, research integrity, confidentiality or transparency.
Authors must disclose material use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools in manuscript preparation, analysis, interpretation, translation or the production of scholarly content, in accordance with the journal's submission requirements. The disclosure should identify the tool and explain its role sufficiently for readers and editors to understand the nature of the assistance.
AI systems cannot be listed as authors because they cannot accept responsibility for the work, approve the final manuscript or fulfil the obligations of authorship. Human authors remain accountable for all submitted content, including AI-assisted text, analysis, references and interpretations.
AI tools must not be used to fabricate or falsify data, invent references, generate false research evidence, conceal plagiarism or misrepresent work that was not performed. Authors must independently verify AI-assisted material, including the accuracy of references, factual claims and analytical outputs.
Reviewers and editors must not submit confidential manuscripts, unpublished data or review materials to unauthorised AI systems. Any permitted AI assistance in editorial work must preserve confidentiality and human accountability.
Failure to disclose material AI use, fabricated AI-generated references or other misuse may lead to additional scrutiny, rejection, correction or further action, depending on the seriousness of the case.
14. Peer-Review Integrity and Confidentiality
IJSSAR uses double-blind peer review to support impartial scholarly assessment. All parties must take reasonable steps to protect the confidentiality and independence of the process.
Authors must not attempt to identify or contact reviewers to influence an assessment. Reviewers must not seek to obtain authors' identities improperly or disclose confidential review information. Editors must not reveal confidential identities except where disclosure is authorised, required by law or necessary to address a serious ethical concern.
The journal prohibits fabricated reviewer identities, manipulated reviewer recommendations, unauthorised third-party interference and other practices intended to compromise the review process.
Where peer-review manipulation is suspected, the journal may suspend the manuscript, verify reviewer identities and contact details, obtain independent assessments, reject the submission or take further action where the evidence supports it.
15. Citation Ethics and Referencing
Authors must cite sources accurately and provide sufficient bibliographic information for readers to identify and verify the materials used. Citations should be relevant to the argument, evidence or scholarly context.
Authors, reviewers and editors must not engage in citation practices designed primarily to inflate personal, institutional, journal or publisher citation metrics. Reviewers must not demand irrelevant citations to their own work, and editors must not require authors to add citations that lack a legitimate scholarly justification.
References must not be fabricated, and citations must not be used to misrepresent what a source actually says. Authors are responsible for checking the accuracy and relevance of references, including those generated or suggested by AI-assisted tools.
16. Funding, Permissions and Research Transparency
Authors must disclose relevant funding sources and accurately describe the role of funders, where applicable. They must obtain necessary permissions for third-party materials and comply with relevant copyright, confidentiality, data protection and research governance requirements.
Where appropriate, manuscripts must include a Data Availability Statement indicating whether the supporting data are publicly accessible, available upon reasonable request, restricted for ethical or legal reasons or not applicable.
The journal may request supporting documentation when reasonably necessary to assess the validity or integrity of a manuscript. Requests will be handled with due regard for participant confidentiality, privacy, legal restrictions and legitimate intellectual property rights.
Authors must not claim that data, materials, approvals or permissions exist when they do not. Material discrepancies between the manuscript and supporting evidence may trigger an integrity assessment.
17. Journal Policy on Intellectual Property
IJSSAR recognises and respects intellectual property rights and is committed to protecting the ownership, originality and lawful use of scholarly works published in the journal. Authors, editors, reviewers and other contributors are required to observe applicable copyright laws, licensing conditions and recognised standards governing intellectual property in academic publishing.
17.1 Copyright Ownership and Author Rights
Authors retain the copyright to their published works unless otherwise agreed in writing. By submitting a manuscript to IJSSAR, authors confirm that the work is their original intellectual contribution, has not been unlawfully reproduced from other sources and does not infringe the intellectual property rights of any individual, institution or organisation.
Publication in IJSSAR does not transfer copyright ownership from authors to the journal. The journal is granted the necessary non-exclusive rights to publish, distribute, preserve and make the accepted work available under the applicable open-access licence.
17.2 Open Access Licensing and Use of Published Materials
IJSSAR operates as a fully open-access journal. Published articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) licence, which permits users to share and adapt published materials for non-commercial purposes, provided that appropriate attribution is given, modifications are indicated where applicable and derivative works are distributed under the same licence.
Authors and readers must observe the terms of the applicable Creative Commons licence when using, reproducing, distributing or adapting published materials. Commercial reuse requires appropriate permission from the relevant copyright holder.
17.3 Originality and Third-Party Intellectual Property
Authors are responsible for ensuring that all manuscripts submitted to IJSSAR are original and that the use of ideas, texts, data, images, tables, figures, instruments and other materials belonging to third parties is properly acknowledged and appropriately authorised.
Where copyrighted materials are reproduced or adapted, authors must obtain the necessary permissions from the relevant copyright holders, except where such use is permitted under applicable copyright exceptions or limitations. Evidence of permission must be provided to the journal upon request.
Proper citation and acknowledgement are required for all sources of intellectual contribution. Plagiarism, unauthorised reproduction, copyright infringement and other forms of intellectual property violation are unacceptable.
17.4 Authorship and Ownership of Research Contributions
Authorship must reflect genuine scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript. Authors are responsible for ensuring that all listed co-authors have made appropriate contributions, approved the final manuscript and consented to its submission and publication.
Disputes concerning authorship, ownership of research outputs or the unauthorised use of intellectual contributions should be resolved through appropriate institutional or other recognised procedures. The journal reserves the right to request clarification or supporting documentation where such disputes arise.
17.5 Protection of the Journal's Intellectual Property
The IJSSAR name, logo, website content, journal design and other original publishing materials are protected by applicable intellectual property laws. Their reproduction, commercial use, modification or distribution without appropriate authorisation is prohibited, except where permitted by law.
The journal does not authorise the unauthorised reproduction, distribution, commercial exploitation or misrepresentation of its published content, name or identity.
17.6 Copyright Infringement and Dispute Resolution
IJSSAR takes allegations of copyright infringement, plagiarism, unauthorised reproduction, misappropriation of intellectual contributions and other intellectual property violations seriously.
Where such concerns arise, the journal will assess the allegation, seek clarification or supporting evidence from the parties concerned and take appropriate action in accordance with its publication ethics and misconduct procedures.
Depending on the nature and seriousness of the violation, actions may include requesting corrections, requiring appropriate permissions, rejecting a manuscript, issuing a correction or retraction, or referring the matter to relevant institutional or legal authorities.
Through this policy, IJSSAR seeks to protect authors' intellectual property rights, promote responsible scholarly communication and ensure the lawful, transparent and ethical dissemination of academic research.
18. Editorial Independence and Financial Integrity
IJSSAR's editorial decisions are based on scholarly and ethical considerations rather than the payment or anticipated payment of an APC.
The journal does not sell acceptance, favourable peer reviews, citations or editorial decisions. Authors are required to pay the applicable article processing charge (APC) only after their manuscripts have completed peer review, undergone any required revisions and received formal acceptance. This policy ensures that APC payments do not influence peer-review outcomes or editorial decisions.
Payment of the APC following acceptance does not guarantee publication in a particular issue. The final placement of an accepted manuscript depends on post-acceptance editorial and production requirements, which may vary from one article to another.
Editors and reviewers must not solicit or accept improper benefits in exchange for favourable treatment. Financial and commercial arrangements must not interfere with peer review, editorial judgement or the accurate presentation of research.
Any suspected attempt to influence a decision through payment, threats, personal relationships or other improper pressure will be referred to the appropriate editorial authority for assessment and action.
19. Handling Allegations and Suspected Misconduct
IJSSAR takes allegations of research or publication misconduct seriously. Concerns may be raised by authors, reviewers, readers, institutions or other individuals. Where possible, allegations should identify the manuscript or published article, describe the concern clearly and provide relevant supporting evidence.
The journal will assess each concern on its merits. The procedure may include the following steps:
- Initial assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or designated editor determines whether the concern is relevant to publication ethics and whether the information provided warrants further inquiry.
- Evidence review: The journal examines the available material, which may include the manuscript, similarity reports, published sources, review records, data or relevant correspondence.
- Request for response: Where appropriate, the author or other relevant party is given an opportunity to respond to the concern and provide an explanation or supporting documentation.
- Further consultation: The journal may seek independent editorial or subject expertise and, where warranted, contact an appropriate institution or research integrity office.
- Editorial determination: The journal determines the appropriate action based on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern and applicable ethical standards.
- Communication and follow-up: The journal communicates its decision to the relevant parties as appropriate and records significant actions taken.
The journal will treat allegations confidentially to the extent practicable and consistent with a fair investigation. It will not make public accusations or impose sanctions solely on the basis of an unverified allegation.
The journal's inquiry is limited to matters within its editorial and publishing remit. Where an allegation requires institutional investigation, the journal may refer the matter to the relevant institution rather than attempt to exercise the institution's investigative authority.
20. Possible Actions in Cases of Misconduct
The response to a substantiated concern will depend on its nature, severity, timing, evidential basis and effect on the reliability of the scholarly record.
Possible actions include:
- Requesting clarification or additional documentation.
- Requiring correction or clarification of a manuscript.
- Returning a submission for revision.
- Rejecting a manuscript before publication.
- Suspending editorial processing while a serious concern is assessed.
- Publishing a correction, expression of concern or retraction notice.
- Informing a relevant institution, research integrity office or other appropriate body where justified.
- Restricting consideration of future submissions in serious or repeated cases, where proportionate and consistent with the journal's procedures.
No action is automatic. The journal will consider the available evidence and the response of relevant parties before determining an appropriate course, except where urgent action is necessary to protect readers or the integrity of the scholarly record.
21. Appeals against Editorial Decisions
Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they believe that it resulted from a material factual error, a significant procedural irregularity or a substantive misunderstanding of the manuscript.
An appeal must be submitted in writing through the journal's official editorial contact. It should identify the decision being challenged, explain the grounds for appeal and provide supporting evidence.
Appeals will be assessed by an editor or designated Editorial Board member who was not responsible for the original decision, where practicable. Independent advice may be sought where necessary.
An appeal is not a guarantee of reconsideration or reversal. The outcome may be to uphold the original decision, request further assessment or revise the decision where the evidence justifies doing so. The journal will communicate its determination to the appellant.
22. Complaints about Editorial Conduct or Journal Operations
IJSSAR will consider complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, publication procedures, delays, conflicts of interest, ethical handling or other matters within the journal's responsibility.
Complaints should be submitted in writing through the journal's official editorial contact and should provide sufficient detail for the concern to be assessed. The journal will handle complaints fairly and confidentially to the extent practicable.
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief or another person directly involved in its handling, the journal should, where practicable, designate an independent editor or appropriate member of the Editorial Board to review the matter.
The journal will communicate the outcome to the complainant. Where a complaint raises a serious concern that cannot be resolved within the journal's remit, referral to an appropriate independent body or institution may be considered.
23. Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections Policy
IJSSAR recognises that scholarly publishing is an ongoing process of knowledge development, critical evaluation and academic engagement. The journal encourages constructive post-publication discussions, scholarly criticism and the responsible exchange of ideas to strengthen the quality, reliability and integrity of published research.
The journal provides mechanisms through which authors, readers, researchers and other interested parties may raise questions, submit observations, identify errors or express concerns regarding articles already published in the journal.
23.1 Post-Publication Discussions and Scholarly Comments
Readers and researchers may submit substantive comments, scholarly observations, critiques or methodological concerns relating to articles published in IJSSAR. Such submissions should be evidence-based, professionally expressed, relevant to the published work and intended to advance scholarly understanding.
Submissions may address issues such as research methodology, interpretation of findings, theoretical arguments, data presentation, factual accuracy or other matters relevant to the scholarly contribution of a published article.
The journal's editorial team will assess submitted comments for scholarly merit, relevance, originality, accuracy and compliance with publication ethics. Where appropriate, the original authors may be invited to respond. Accepted comments and corresponding author responses may be published as separate contributions or linked to the original article to facilitate academic dialogue and preserve the scholarly record.
23.2 Submission and Assessment of Post-Publication Concerns
Readers, authors, reviewers and other stakeholders may report suspected errors, inaccuracies, plagiarism, data irregularities, ethical violations, copyright infringement, undisclosed conflicts of interest or other concerns relating to published articles by contacting the Editor-in-Chief through the journal's official editorial email address.
All concerns should, as far as possible, include sufficient details and supporting evidence to enable an appropriate assessment. The editorial team will evaluate credible submissions and may request additional information from the complainant, the authors or other relevant parties.
Where necessary, the journal may consult independent experts, editorial advisers, institutional research ethics committees or relevant institutions to establish the facts. All parties involved will be treated fairly, and authors will ordinarily be given an opportunity to respond to allegations concerning their published work.
23.3 Corrections and Amendments
Where an error or omission is identified in a published article that does not invalidate its overall findings or conclusions, IJSSAR may publish a formal correction or corrigendum, as appropriate.
Corrections may address errors involving author names or affiliations, factual inaccuracies, typographical errors, tables, figures, references, data presentation or other elements that require amendment to maintain the accuracy and clarity of the published record.
All formal corrections will clearly identify the affected article, describe the nature of the amendment and provide a link to the original publication. The original article will remain accessible, with an appropriate correction notice or other visible indication of the amendment.
23.4 Expressions of Concern
Where credible allegations or questions arise concerning the reliability, ethical compliance or integrity of a published article, but the investigation remains inconclusive or cannot be completed within a reasonable period, IJSSAR may publish an Expression of Concern.
An Expression of Concern will inform readers that questions have been raised regarding the article and that the matter is under investigation or awaiting further clarification. It will be linked to the affected article and may be followed by a correction, retraction or other editorial action when the investigation is concluded.
23.5 Retractions
IJSSAR may retract a published article where substantial evidence establishes that its findings or scholarly integrity have been seriously compromised. Grounds for retraction may include fabricated or falsified data, serious plagiarism, duplicate publication, unethical research practices, significant undisclosed conflicts of interest, copyright violations or other forms of serious research or publication misconduct.
Retraction decisions will be based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the identified concerns. Authors will ordinarily be informed of the concerns and given an opportunity to respond before a final decision is made.
Retracted articles will normally remain accessible in the journal's archive to preserve the scholarly record but will be clearly identified as retracted. The journal will publish a formal retraction notice explaining the reasons for the action, subject to applicable legal and ethical considerations.
23.6 Appeals and Requests for Reconsideration
Authors who disagree with a correction, Expression of Concern, retraction or other post-publication editorial decision may submit a reasoned appeal to the Editor-in-Chief, providing relevant explanations and supporting evidence.
Appeals will be assessed impartially and may be referred to an independent editor or appropriate external expert where necessary. The final decision will be communicated to the concerned parties, with appropriate reasons.
23.7 Transparency and Preservation of the Scholarly Record
IJSSAR is committed to maintaining an accurate, transparent and reliable scholarly record. All formal post-publication notices, including corrections, Expressions of Concern and retractions, will be appropriately linked to the affected articles and made accessible to readers.
The journal will follow recognised publication ethics standards and applicable guidelines, including relevant recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), when handling post-publication discussions, corrections and retractions.
Through this policy, IJSSAR seeks to promote constructive academic engagement, accountability, transparency and the continuous improvement of published scholarly research.
24. Manuscript Withdrawal and Post-Acceptance Concerns
Authors may request withdrawal of a manuscript before acceptance by submitting a written request authorised by all contributing authors. Requests concerning accepted manuscripts will be considered on their merits and may require a clear justification and confirmation of author agreement.
Where a manuscript has entered production, received a DOI or had its publication metadata deposited, withdrawal will not ordinarily result in silent removal from the scholarly record. A formal notice may be required where withdrawal is justified after that stage.
If serious ethical concerns arise before publication, the journal may suspend production or withhold publication while the matter is assessed. If concerns arise after publication, the journal will consider whether a correction, expression of concern, retraction or other appropriate action is warranted. Further operational details are provided in the Journal Policies.
25. Protection against Retaliation and Abuse of the Process
IJSSAR expects concerns about publication ethics to be raised responsibly and considered fairly. Individuals who raise concerns in good faith should not be subjected to retaliation through the journal's editorial processes.
At the same time, knowingly false allegations, threats, harassment, deliberate attempts to obstruct peer review or repeated abusive communications will not be treated as legitimate substitutes for evidence-based complaints.
The journal will assess such conduct proportionately and may take reasonable steps to protect the confidentiality, safety and proper functioning of its editorial process.
26. Confidentiality and Record Management
Manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence and supporting materials are handled as confidential information unless disclosure is authorised, required by law or necessary for a legitimate ethical investigation.
The journal will limit access to confidential materials to individuals who require them for editorial, review, production or research-integrity purposes. Personal and sensitive information must be handled responsibly and in accordance with applicable legal and ethical requirements.
Where an investigation requires consultation with an institution or other appropriate body, the journal will disclose only information reasonably necessary for the purpose, subject to applicable obligations.
Editorial records relating to significant decisions, complaints and integrity concerns should be retained appropriately to support accountability and consistent decision-making.
27. Relationship with the Journal's Other Policies
This statement establishes the ethical principles and procedures governing publication integrity at IJSSAR. It should be read alongside the journal's Journal Policies, Instructions for Authors, peer-review procedures, publication fees information and other applicable editorial guidance.
The Journal Policies document governs operational matters such as submission procedures, publication charges, issue scheduling, production deadlines, open access, copyright, licensing, digital preservation and publication capacity. This statement governs ethical responsibilities, suspected misconduct, complaints, appeals and actions required to protect the scholarly record.
Where an ethical concern arises in connection with an operational procedure, the journal will apply the relevant policies together, giving priority to research integrity, fairness, confidentiality and the accuracy of the scholarly record.
28. Review and Contact
The Editorial Board reviews this statement periodically and may revise it to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, recognised publication ethics guidance and the journal's experience in applying its policies. Material revisions will be reflected on the journal's official website.
Questions or concerns relating to publication ethics, research integrity, suspected misconduct or the application of this statement should be directed to:
The Editor-in-Chief, International Journal of Sub-Saharan African Research (IJSSAR)
Department of Mass Communication,
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities,
Ebonyi State University,
P.M.B.053, Abakaliki,
Ebonyi State,
Nigeria Email: editorIJSSAR@gmail.com
Journal Identifiers
eISSN: 3043-4459
pISSN: 3043-4467
Last Updated: 16 November, 2026